Looking Inside the Black Box: The Importance of Causal Mechanism and Treatment Effect Heterogeneity in Experimentally Evaluated Criminal Justice Interventions*

This paper discusses limitations of the “black-box” experimental archetype by highlighting the narrowness of outcome-focused approaches. For a more complete understanding of the nuanced implications of policies and programs, this study calls for an investigation of causal mechanism and treatment effect heterogeneity in experimentally evaluated interventions. This study draws on two distinct but closely related empirical studies, one undertaken by Na and Paternoster (2012) and the other by Na, Loughran, and Paternoster (2015), that go beyond the estimation of a population average treatment effect by adopting more recent methodological advancements that are still underappreciated and underutilized in evaluation research.